Enjoy free shipping on orders over $70!
Log in
Cart (
0
)
Home
Popcorn
Candy
Gifts
Our Story
Candy-Nostalgia
All Candy
544 Items
Bulk
163 Items
Nostalgia
133 Items
Boxed
66 Items
Pucker Up
37 Items
Fun Stuff
89 Items
Cotton Candy
9 Items
Specialty
13 Items
Sugar Free
20 Items
Vegan
6 Items
Candy
Nostalgia
Page 1 of 3
Filter by:
All Nostalgia
Chocolate
Christmas
Pez
Sort by:
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically: A-Z
Alphabetically: Z-A
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Date: New to Old
Date: Old to New
5th Avenue Bar
Nostalgia
5th Avenue Bar
$1.95
Abba-Zaba Bar
Nostalgia
Abba-Zaba Bar
$1.95
Airheads Bites
Nostalgia
Airheads Bites
Sold Out
Andes Peppermint Bark Snap Bar
Nostalgia
Andes Peppermint Bark Snap Bar
$1.95
Andes Snap Bar
Nostalgia
Andes Snap Bar
$1.95
Beemans Gum
Nostalgia
Beemans Gum
$0.95
Big Cherry - Milk Chocolate
Nostalgia
Big Cherry - Milk Chocolate
$1.50
Big Hunk Bar
Nostalgia
Big Hunk Bar
$1.95
Big League Chew - Blue Raspberry
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Blue Raspberry
$2.50
Big League Chew - Grape
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Grape
$2.50
Big League Chew - Original
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Original
$2.50
Big League Chew - Sour Apple
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Sour Apple
$2.50
Big League Chew - Strawberry
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Strawberry
$2.50
Big League Chew - Watermelon
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Watermelon
Sold Out
Big League Chew Baseballs
Nostalgia
Big League Chew Baseballs
$2.50
Black Cow Bar
Nostalgia
Black Cow Bar
$1.50
Black Jack Gum
Nostalgia
Black Jack Gum
Sold Out
Bottlecaps Nostalgia Rolls
Nostalgia
Bottlecaps Nostalgia Rolls
$1.95
Candy Buttons
Nostalgia
Candy Buttons
$1.95
Carnival Pops
Nostalgia
Carnival Pops
Sold Out
Charleston Chew - Chocolate
Nostalgia
Charleston Chew - Chocolate
$1.50
Charleston Chew - Strawberry
Nostalgia
Charleston Chew - Strawberry
$1.50
Charleston Chew - Vanilla
Nostalgia
Charleston Chew - Vanilla
$1.50
Chick-O-Stick
Nostalgia
Chick-O-Stick
$1.95
Chimes Ginger Chews - Cayenne Lemon
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Cayenne Lemon
$2.95
Chimes Ginger Chews - Lemon
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Lemon
$2.95
Chimes Ginger Chews - Mango
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Mango
$2.95
Chimes Ginger Chews - Orange
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Orange
$2.95
Chimes Ginger Chews - Original
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Original
$2.95
Chunky Bar
Nostalgia
Chunky Bar
$1.50
Circus Peanuts Peg Bag
Nostalgia
Circus Peanuts Peg Bag
$3.95
Claey's Lemon Drops
Nostalgia
Claey's Lemon Drops
$2.50
Claey's Wild Cherry Drops
Nostalgia
Claey's Wild Cherry Drops
$2.50
Clove Gum
Nostalgia
Clove Gum
$0.95
Cupcake Popping Candy
Nostalgia
Cupcake Popping Candy
$1.50
Fruit Stripe Gum
Nostalgia
Fruit Stripe Gum
Sold Out
Fun Dip - Cherry Yum
Nostalgia
Fun Dip - Cherry Yum
Sold Out
Fun Dip - Razz Apple
Nostalgia
Fun Dip - Razz Apple
Sold Out
Ghirardelli Squares - Peppermint Bark
Nostalgia
Ghirardelli Squares - Peppermint Bark
Sold Out
Giant Chewy Sweetarts
Nostalgia
Giant Chewy Sweetarts
Sold Out
Goetze Original Caramel Creams
Nostalgia
Goetze Original Caramel Creams
$3.50
Gold Mine Bubble Gum
Nostalgia
Gold Mine Bubble Gum
$2.50
Goo Goo Cluster
Nostalgia
Goo Goo Cluster
$1.95
Goo Goo Cluster - Pecan
Nostalgia
Goo Goo Cluster - Pecan
$1.95
Hershey's Chocolate Bar
Nostalgia
Hershey's Chocolate Bar
$2.95
Hershey's Chocolate Bar with Almonds
Nostalgia
Hershey's Chocolate Bar with Almonds
$2.95
Hershey's Cookies 'n' Creme Bar
Nostalgia
Hershey's Cookies 'n' Creme Bar
$1.95
Hi-Chew Berry Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Berry Mix
Sold Out
1
2
3
Next
"
