Enjoy free shipping on orders over $70!
Log in
Cart (
0
)
Home
Popcorn
Candy
Gifts
Our Story
Candy-Nostalgia
All Candy
556 Items
Bulk
166 Items
Nostalgia
142 Items
Boxed
71 Items
Pucker Up
40 Items
Fun Stuff
80 Items
Cotton Candy
12 Items
Specialty
11 Items
Sugar Free
21 Items
Vegan
5 Items
Candy
Nostalgia
Page 1 of 3
Filter by:
All Nostalgia
Chocolate
Pez
Sort by:
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically: A-Z
Alphabetically: Z-A
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Date: New to Old
Date: Old to New
5th Avenue Bar
Nostalgia
5th Avenue Bar
$1.95
Abba-Zaba Bar
Nostalgia
Abba-Zaba Bar
$1.95
Airheads Bites
Nostalgia
Airheads Bites
$1.75
Airheads Ropes
Nostalgia
Airheads Ropes
$1.95
Almond Joy Bar
Nostalgia
Almond Joy Bar
$1.50
Andes Snap Bar
Nostalgia
Andes Snap Bar
$1.95
Astro Pops
Nostalgia
Astro Pops
Sold Out
Beemans Gum
Nostalgia
Beemans Gum
$0.95
Big Cherry - Milk Chocolate
Nostalgia
Big Cherry - Milk Chocolate
$1.50
Big Hunk Bar
Nostalgia
Big Hunk Bar
$1.95
Big League Chew - Blue Raspberry
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Blue Raspberry
$2.50
Big League Chew - Grape
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Grape
Sold Out
Big League Chew - Original
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Original
$2.50
Big League Chew - Sour Apple
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Sour Apple
$2.50
Big League Chew - Strawberry
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Strawberry
$2.50
Big League Chew - Watermelon
Nostalgia
Big League Chew - Watermelon
$2.50
Big League Chew Baseballs
Nostalgia
Big League Chew Baseballs
Sold Out
Black Cow Bar
Nostalgia
Black Cow Bar
$1.50
Black Jack Gum
Nostalgia
Black Jack Gum
$0.95
Bottlecaps Nostalgia Rolls
Nostalgia
Bottlecaps Nostalgia Rolls
Sold Out
C Howard's Violet Scented Gum
Nostalgia
C Howard's Violet Scented Gum
$1.25
Candy Buttons
Nostalgia
Candy Buttons
$1.95
Carnival Pops
Nostalgia
Carnival Pops
$2.50
Charleston Chew - Chocolate
Nostalgia
Charleston Chew - Chocolate
$1.50
Charleston Chew - Strawberry
Nostalgia
Charleston Chew - Strawberry
$1.50
Charleston Chew - Vanilla
Nostalgia
Charleston Chew - Vanilla
Sold Out
Cherry Mash
Nostalgia
Cherry Mash
$1.50
Chick-O-Stick
Nostalgia
Chick-O-Stick
$1.95
Chimes Ginger Chews - Cayenne Lemon
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Cayenne Lemon
$2.50
Chimes Ginger Chews - Lemon
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Lemon
$2.50
Chimes Ginger Chews - Mango
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Mango
$2.50
Chimes Ginger Chews - Orange
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Orange
$2.50
Chimes Ginger Chews - Original
Nostalgia
Chimes Ginger Chews - Original
$2.50
Chocolate Big Hunk
Nostalgia
Chocolate Big Hunk
$1.95
Chunky Bar
Nostalgia
Chunky Bar
$1.50
Circus Peanuts Peg Bag
Nostalgia
Circus Peanuts Peg Bag
Sold Out
Claey's Lemon Drops
Nostalgia
Claey's Lemon Drops
$2.50
Claey's Wild Cherry Drops
Nostalgia
Claey's Wild Cherry Drops
$2.50
Clove Gum
Nostalgia
Clove Gum
$0.95
Cupcake Popping Candy
Nostalgia
Cupcake Popping Candy
Sold Out
Fort Knox Chocolate Coins
Nostalgia
Fort Knox Chocolate Coins
$2.50
Fruit Stripe Gum
Nostalgia
Fruit Stripe Gum
$2.25
Fun Dip - Cherry Yum
Nostalgia
Fun Dip - Cherry Yum
$0.50
Fun Dip - Razz Apple
Nostalgia
Fun Dip - Razz Apple
$0.50
Ghirardelli Squares - Peppermint Bark
Nostalgia
Ghirardelli Squares - Peppermint Bark
$0.75
Giant Chewy Sweetarts
Nostalgia
Giant Chewy Sweetarts
Sold Out
Goetze Original Caramel Creams
Nostalgia
Goetze Original Caramel Creams
$3.50
Gold Mine Bubble Gum
Nostalgia
Gold Mine Bubble Gum
$2.50
1
2
3
Next
"
